Eclectic Homeschool OnlineVisit EHO Lite
An easy to navigate site for those just
starting out
or planning for the next school year.

EHO Advertiser.
Eclectic Homeschool Curriculum Fair
Find homeschool resources by all the top publishers.
Subscribe to the
EHO Newsletters

EcleticHS Discussion List
Eclectic Homeschool Newsletter
Support Group Leaders
Feel free to post any part or all of our EHO Newsletter to your email or snailmail lists.
Our information sheet is available for handing out to your members.
To submit your resources for review, please read our review guidelines.
Make a Donation to EHO
Summer Reading - books for all ages.
Featured Resource
Shop Amazon - Help Fund EHO
Homeschool News
Our Staff Blogs
Search the Web from EHO
Join the Campaign

From Nature Stories to Natural Science: A Holistic Approach to Science for Families
Reviews Index

From Nature Stories to Natural Science: A Holistic Approach to Science for Families

Printer Friendly Version

Publisher: Christopherus Homeschool Resources
Author: Donna Simmons

List Price: $35

Ages: Adult

Reviewed By: Robin McDonald

If you're tired of the same old science texts, over and over, and need a change of pace, consider Donna Simmons' new book entitled From Nature Stories to Natural Science: A Holistic Approach to Science for Families. A science book in part, this book also offers homeschool encouragement and insight from a homeschooling mom.

As Simmons says in the preface, "This was a book that wanted to be written! I had started out writing a general overview of Waldorf education for homeschoolers, but my love of working with children in nature came to the fore and before I knew it I was writing From Nature Stories to Natural Science."

This 150-page spiral bound book includes topics such as:

An introduction to Waldorf Education with a special look at Hands, Hearts, and Heads approach to education (similar in concept to the Charlotte Mason approach of Knowledge of God, Man, and The Universe).
A special excerpt on Rudolf Steiner and Anthroposophy (see note below)
A discussion on Goethe's Way of Science (Steiner translated the writings of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe)
An explanation of Science in the Waldorf School Curriculum
Suggestions for Setting the Scene - cultivating a child's awe for science in your own back yard
A look at Your Garden
Detailed explanations for each grade:
Early Years Through Kindergarten
First Through Third Grades
Fourth and Fifth Grades
Sixth Through Eighth Grades
High School

Simmons closely follows the Waldorf approach to science, with suggestions for each grade. For example, in fourth grade, students are taught a Man and Animal block (a block is similar to a unit study). This block teaches the differences and similarities between humans and animals in a conceptual sense (swift as a deer, eyesight like an eagle, courageous as a lion, etc.). In high school, Simmons tells us that most teens study biology, physics, astronomy and geology, which are being revisited from more conceptual elementary and middle school introductions to these courses.

This book, while very Waldorfy in concept, can be applied to science activities in any eclectic homeschool. Simmons makes practical suggestions for the homeschool that has multiple children and, as always, in her pragmatic and creative style, she suggests ideas such as field trips to observatories, rivers, and gives a plethora of reading and web site suggestions for each level. While I was reading this book, I felt like she was sitting beside me, talking to me in a casual, conversational style.

A very personal and hands-on teacher, Simmons has a background in education. She has been involved with Waldorf education since she was four years old, when she was sent to a Waldorf kindergarten and continued this education through graduation. She later studied child development and taught at two Waldorf Schools in England. She eventually became a youth worker, drawing on her rich childhood experiences to find creative ways to work with some very challenging inner city youth. Donna's perspective on Waldorf education is largely colored by this work, and as a pragmatic homeschooling mom. She is eager to find "what works" in different situations. Children come out occasionally to the hobby farm in Wisconsin where she and her husband, Paul Newton, a homeopath, live and learn with their two sons, 12-year-old Daniel and 10-year-old Gabriel.

To get on-the-spot information from Simmons, one simply needs to join her Yahoo!Group, entitled Waldorf_at_Home, and visit her web site at

Donna and Paul recently set up Christopherus Homeschool Resources with the aim to help homeschooling parents find a relationship to Waldorf education at home, one that will vary according to each family's situation. Christopherus provides a telephone consultation service with Donna, a correspondence course in writing, an informative and ever expanding website, and a series of curriculum materials written by Donna. Parents are encouraged to sign up for Christopherus' free monthly e-mail newsletter, The Homeschool Journey.

Please note that some people involved in Waldorf education study a philosophy known as Anthroposophy, based on the writings and lectures of Rudolf Steiner. There are concepts in Anthroposophy that are based on Christian beliefs, so there are references to Christianity in Waldorf education. For example, school festivals often follow the Liturgical Christian calendar, and children learn about saints in the second grade and Old Testament stories in the third grade.

On the other hand, not all of Steiner's esoteric ideas are accepted in, and some run counter to, traditional Christian theology. Consequently, there are problematic areas that cause some Christians to shy away from Waldorf education as a whole.

As a Christian and an eclectic homeschooler, I have not found the practical Waldorf teaching methods to be incongruent with my Christian walk. The introduction of art, music, and movement in a curriculum based on a child's development brings richness to its delivery. The use of physical activity with recitation helps my son's ability to process information. Hence, I am comfortable taking what I want, leaving the rest, and adding my own Christian beliefs to the spiritual aspects of Waldorf education.

Some people, especially those who are new to Christianity, may not be comfortable doing this. It is always wise to prayerfully use discernment when reading any Waldorf-based materials, in order to separate the wheat from the chaff.
More Information
Available From: Christopherus Homeschool Resources
Address: P.O. Box 231, Viroqua, WI 54665
Phone: 608.637.8031
Other Notes:

Add Your Own Review

Robin McDonald
Robin McDonald is a mom who actually does Windows, since she used to work at Microsoft! Robin resigned from her full-time writing job to homeschool her children. She freelances, and teaches art and writing classes.
Copyright © 2004 Eclectic Homeschool Association


New Homeschool Resources - Visit the Eclectic Homeschool Resource Center for more discounted resources.

About EHO | Masthead | Financial Info | Contact Us | Writing for EHO | Get Your Product Reviewed
Linking to this site | Advertise| Submit a Site | Reprinting Articles | Reviewing for EHO | Privacy | Search

This website is Copyright ©1997-2010 Eclectic Homeschool Association, All rights reserved.
This site was authored by Beverly S. Krueger. All contents belong to the Eclectic Homeschool Association or the original authors. Reproduction of this World Wide Web Site in whole or in part is prohibited without permission. All rights reserved. Trademarks may not be used without permission of the trademark owner. Details about our reprint policies are available.

Publishers: Tammy Cardwell, Jean Hall, and Beverly Krueger are the only persons authorized to make product requests on behalf of the Eclectic Homeschool Online. If you receive requests from any other individuals in our name, please do not comply.

The staff at EHO try very hard to answer all our mail. We have had many of our responses to email returned as undeliverable. We also delete unread a great deal of spam. If your email message header sounds like it is spam, it will be deleted. "You Should See This!" or "Have I got something great for you" are examples of subject lines that would be deleted unread. If you use 'EHO' in the subject line it will not be deleted unread. If you have not received an answer to your question, please resend your email. We usually have a delay of 1 to 2 weeks in answering email because of the number of requests we get. Those wishing to request links to our site should read our linking page before writing us. All our resources are posted online. We do not mail information to postal addresses.

This Site Uses the Following for Website Services:

OpenCube CSS Menu

XIGLA - Absolute Banner Manager

Scripture taken from the New King James Version. Copyright © 1979, 1980, 1982 by Thomas Nelson, Inc. Used by permission. All rights reserved.

Thank your for vising the Eclectic Homeschool Online, we hope you found the resources to make your homeschooling journey easier.

homeschool information